Million Dollar Recipe, Nut Free Version! “Soynutty Pie Crust Clusters”

As I might have mentioned 100 a few times, I was lucky enough to be a contestant in the last two Pillsbury Bake Off Contests.  The winner of the 47th contest was just announced live on The Chew tv show the other day, and boy was I thrilled that my new friend and fellow Virginian, Beth Royals, walked away with the Grand Prize of 1 MILLION dollars!  Her absolutely addictive “Peanutty Pie Crust Clusters” are amazing, and I would encourage you to make a batch for your holiday cookie tray or exchange parties.  The original recipe can be found here. Not wanting to be deprived of these treats in my nut-free home, I set about making a peanut-free version, “Soynutty Pie Crust Clusters” .  It is a tad bit more involved than the original version (mostly because of the toffee chips!), but still took me around 30 minutes to throw together.

First, cut the pie dough into 16 strips in both directions.  I did this on top of parchment, with my pizza cutter.

The cut pie crust for my Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters

Then you spread the little pieces apart a bit, so that they don’t stick together.  This part would totally appeal to those of you that are obsessed with crossword puzzles.  It was kind of fun!  Kids can help make this recipe easily, by the way…

Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters dough on the baking sheet

Then you bake them at 450 degrees for 6-8 minutes or until light golden brown.

Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters dough baked

While those were baking, I set about making my own toffee.  It is super simple, takes about ten minutes, and is necessary if you want to avoid nut products.  You also could buy nut free hard candies, such as Werthers Originals and crush them up, if you wanted to skip this step.

Just place butter and sugar in a pot over medium-high heat and whisk occasionally until it reaches 305 degrees (hard crack stage).  If you don’t have a candy thermometer, it will turn a lovely toffee color at this point.  Pour out onto a lined pan onto parchment or Silpat mat.  Let cool and bust into pieces with a mallet.  Told you this was fun!

Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters toffee 1Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters toffee 2Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters toffee 3

Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters toffee 4

Not only do you get to bash toffee, but you get to smash pretzels in this version as well!  Great holiday stress relief.

Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters Smashed Pretzels

Now, put your white chocolate chips into a microwave safe bowl.  An aside about white chocolate chips- It is hard to find a coconut oil-free brand that is not made in a plant with nuts, but Trader Joes makes them, and they are perfect for this recipe.  They do contain milk, however.

Anyhow, stick one bag of the white chocolate chips with 1 tablespoon crisco (butter variety or plain works as well), 1 tablespoon of soy-nut or sunbutter, and microwave in 30 second intervals, stirring well until completely melted.

Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters soy nut butter and white chocolate chips
The chips and Soynutty butter I used.

Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters soy nut butter and white chocolate chips in the bowl

Now all my bits and pieces are ready to go!  Just fold the pie crust bits, the smashed up toffee, and the broken pretzels into the melted chocolate goodness.

Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters ingredients

Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters ingredients mixed

Dollop onto parchment in little clusters.

Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters on a baking sheet

Pop into the fridge for 15 minutes and you have the best sweet and salty munchie ever invented….1 million dollars good!  Enjoy.

Nut Free Pie Crust Clusters yum
The focus group loved these!

Some other allergy thoughts- If you have a peanut allergy, but are not allergic to tree nuts, you could add pecans or hazelnuts, lightly chopped.

If you are gluten-free, you could use Pillsbury’s gluten-free pie and pastry dough in place of the crust, and make sure to use gluten free pretzels.

If you are Milk free- you could use milk free chocolate chips in place of the white chips. A brand like Enjoy Life would work well. You could make the toffee with non-dairy margarine instead of butter.

If you are allergic to soy, use sunbutter or golden peabutter.

Cookie butter might also rock in this! Just a thought…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close